Some higher-end soundbars now come equipped with Dolby Atmos technology, which allows them to create a more immersive sound experience by firing audio from different speakers in different directions. This can help to replicate the experience of a full surround sound system, even though the soundbar itself is limited to one location.
Indeed, Dolby Atmos-enabled soundbars use upward-firing speakers to bounce sound off your ceiling and create a more three-dimensional soundstage. While a soundbar with Dolby Atmos can create the impression of sound coming from above or below, it can still struggle to replicate the full directional sound experience of a discrete surround sound system. With a discrete system, you have speakers positioned around the room to create a more immersive and realistic soundstage. Even a budget surround sound system can provide a more convincing and immersive 3D sound experience than even the best soundbars with Dolby Atmos technology, even if the sound quality of the speakers is lower.
A soundbar can be a great option for those who want a more immersive sound experience without the hassle of setting up a full surround sound system. However, it’s important to note that not all soundbars with Dolby Atmos are created equal, and some may provide a more convincing surround sound experience than others. But none can recreate the experience of a discrete 5.1, 7.1, … system that has the speaker volumes and timings properly calibrated with a 3D microphone, which today is a feature even included with most mid grade AV receivers. Our ears are sensitive, and you will notice the difference which is not subtle.
Recently, some manufacturers combine the convenience of a soundbar with the immersive experience of a discrete system. One example is the JBL Bar 5.1 – Channel 4K Ultra HD Soundbar with True Wireless Surround Speakers. This soundbar includes two detachable satellite speakers that can be placed around the room. These can be placed at the back of the room for a more convincing surround sound experience, and are charged from the side of the sound bar. The JBL Bar 5.1 also includes a wireless subwoofer to handle the lower frequencies.
Choosing between a soundbar and a discrete surround sound system depends on your budget and priorities. If you’re on a budget, a soundbar under $250 is a good option for an easy-to-use and space-saving solution. The Bose TV Speaker is a safe choice on that budget. However, if you want a more immersive sound experience, a discrete surround sound system with an AV receiver is the best option, even if it requires more setup time and space. For those who want a balance of convenience and immersion, a soundbar with wireless speakers under $750, like the JBL Bar 5.1, can be a good compromise. Ultimately, it’s important to choose the option that fits your budget and preferences, as both soundbars and discrete surround sound systems have their pros and cons.